First came the good news. After attending community college, Ricky Korba was accepted into California State University, Bakersfield as a transfer student. But when she logged into her student account, she got hit in the gut: most of her previous classes didn’t count.
She was told that the university had rejected most of her science classes because they were considered less rigorous than at Bakersfield, although some used the same textbooks. Several other courses were rejected because Ms. Korba exceeded the maximum number of credits that could be transferred.
Now chemistry and music are retaking subjects that she has already passed once. This will add her a year to her studies, as well as at least $20,000 in tuition and fees.
Why did we write this
How can a better alignment of courses offered by schools help students who transfer to community colleges earn a four-year degree? The Monitor, in collaboration with six other newsrooms, explores the challenges facing U.S. community colleges and possible solutions in a series of articles called “Saving the College Dream.”
“It seems like a waste of time,” says Ms. Korba of Sonora, California. “I thought I should have gone to CSU and started hard classes and done a bunch of cool labs.”
Every year, hundreds of thousands of students enroll in community colleges, hoping to later transfer to university. It’s advertised as a cheaper way to get a bachelor’s degree, an educational gimmick in the world ever rising Cost of education.
However, reality is rarely so simple. For some students, the transfer process becomes a maze so confusing that it derails their college plans.
Among the nearly 1 million students who enrolled at a community college in 2016, only one in seven earned a bachelor’s degree within six years, according to the National Student Information Center.
One of the biggest hurdles is known as losing credit – when students take classes that never count towards a degree.
Sometimes it’s the result of bad counseling. Without clear guidance from local colleges, students choose courses they don’t need. The fault may also lie with four-year colleges, which have different rules for evaluating transfer points. Some are more picky than others.
However, the result is often the same. Students take longer to complete their degree, which costs more in tuition. For many, the extra work becomes unbearable. Eventually, about half of community college students drop out.
“Some students are completely frustrated by this,” says Jesse Ryan, vice president of the Campaign for College Opportunity research group. “These systems were designed for colleges and teachers, not for students.”
The search for solutions met with scattered success. In many states, colleges and universities have formed partnerships to guarantee the transfer of certain classes. More than a dozen states have adopted uniform class numbering systems to ensure uniformity in schools.
However, the problems remain frustratingly common.
A recent study by the City University of New York system found that among students who switched from a local college to an undergraduate program, almost half lost at least some of their jobs. On average, these students lost almost an entire semester.
“The path from community college to a bachelor’s degree is full of holes,” says Alexandra Logue, one of the researchers and a former provost of the CUNY system. The worst results are seen among blacks, Hispanics and low-income students, who are more likely to start in colleges, she says.
Ms. Korba, in her early 20s, believes she is learning the right classes at Columbia College, a community college in Sonora. She worked with a consultant and used an online catalog that showed which courses were to be transferred to the California State University schools.
But when officials in Bakersfield looked at the transcript, they said that most of her classes would not count towards her major.
University officials declined to comment on Ms. Korba’s case, but said a small number of transfer points could fall into a gray area and require further verification. Duane Cantrell, director of admissions at Bakersfield, said credit losses are rare and many classes from California community colleges are automatically accepted.
Ms Korba has one more year of school to go and will likely run out of financial aid before she graduates. She plans to go to school part-time and work longer hours so she can pay tuition and rent, but she’s wondering how long she can juggle it all.
“I’m worried about how much more I’ll be interested in studying than just getting money from work,” she says.
Stories like hers are not uncommon, especially in California, which has long been trying to connect its 116 community colleges with more than 30 public universities.
Mea Montañez will graduate from San Francisco State University (SFSU) in May, but only after revisiting nearly a year of classes she already took at a community college. The school didn’t accept her psychology classes—her main subject—because they weren’t considered appropriate.
“I go to courses and I say, ‘That’s exactly what I took,’ says Ms Montañez, 30. “If anything, it was a lot harder at the local college level.”
University officials say classes may look the same on paper, but the details of what is taught don’t always match up, though they acknowledged room for improvement.
“Loan losses happen, but we’ve been working on this for a long time,” says Laurie Beth Way, dean of the Faculty of Higher Education at SFSU.
When students transfer to any school, their transcripts are often reviewed by teachers. For example, biology professors decided whether to take biology lessons from another school into account.
But those judgments can be tinged with stigma (some faculty look down on community colleges) and financial incentives, says CUNY’s Ms. Logue. The waiver of loans, she said, means students have to attend more classes at their school. Faculty also sometimes hold a higher standard for accepting a class into a major than simply accepting it as a general requirement.
“It’s money, and it keeps people’s jobs,” she says. “But that’s a very short-sighted point of view.”
Some states have intervened to remove subjectivity from the process. Under the new Maryland rule, a class must be accepted if it shares 70% of the learning objectives with a comparable class. If loans are denied, students and community colleges must receive an explanation.
California made headway by passing a 2010 law requiring community colleges to offer special associate degrees that guarantee admission to the CSU campus. The 2021 law will put all eligible students on this path, unless they opt out, and will create a set of general education classes that must be accepted at all public universities.
Two Virginia colleges have gone further. From day one on campus, Northern Virginia Community College students are offered a direct path to earning a bachelor’s degree at nearby George Mason University. Students get dual enrollment at both schools and they can choose from 87 academic paths that tell them exactly which classes they need.
Known as Promote, the program is designed to minimize credit losses and increase the number of graduates. George Mason is working to extend this model to other community colleges.
“Students understand what is expected of them from day one,” says Jason Dodge, program director. “They know the carpet won’t slip out from under them along the way.”
Editor’s Note: This story is part of the Save the College Dream Project, a collaboration with The Associated Press and The Monitor, AL.com, The Dallas Morning News, The Hechinger Report, The Post and Courier in Charleston, South Carolina, and The Seattle Times. , supported by Journalists Solutions Network.